Store
Baked Daily, Harvested Fresh
Savor the best of Witten Farm Market with our freshly baked goods made daily, plus year-round produce and seasonal favorites that everyone loves! From juicy fruits and vegetables to pies so irresistible we bake over 5,000 in just three days for Thanksgiving, our store has something special for every season. Be sure to place your holiday pre-orders early to guarantee your favorites and enjoy the freshest flavors all year long!
Product successfully added to your cart. View Cart
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Specialty Packaged Cookies
$6.99 - $12.99Successfully Added to your Shopping CartAdding to Cart... -
Gourmet Packaged Cookies (1/2 Dozen)
$9.99Successfully Added to your Shopping CartAdding to Cart... -
￩￫
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Chocolate Covered Pretzel Rods
$2.99Maximum quantity exceededMinimum purchase amount of 0 is required -
-
-
Stop by and explore our wide selection of delicious, freshly baked treats.
Bakery items are available year-round exclusively at our Witten Farm Market location at 3341 Winchester Pike, Columbus, OH 43232.
Convenient Pre-Orders, Just a Click Away
- 24/7 Online Pre-Orders – Place your order anytime, day or night, for your favorite bakery items and fresh produce.
- 24-Hour Notice – We need about 24 hours to prepare your pre-order. When placing your order, you'll be prompted to select your preferred pickup date and time.
- Pay at Pickup – No need to pay online. You can pay for your order when you arrive at the market to pick it up.
- Flexible Pickup – While missing your pickup time usually isn’t an issue, we’ll hold your order until the end of the pickup day. However, for Thanksgiving and Christmas orders, it’s essential to collect your items at the scheduled time due to high demand.
Large Orders & Adjustments
- Bulk Pre-Orders – Ordering 10 or more items? Give us a call at (614) 235-2014 to ensure we can accommodate your large order.
- Need to Change or Cancel? – If you need to make changes or cancel your order, please call us directly at (614) 235-2014. We’re happy to help!
Special Holiday Product Availability
- Valentine’s Day – Available starting January 31st
- Easter – Available 2 weeks before Easter
- Thanksgiving – Available starting September 30th
- Christmas – Available the day after Thanksgiving
Be sure to order early for these popular seasonal treats!