Bakery

Savor the Sweetness of Our Local Bakery

10% off online orders

Baked with Love, Freshly Made for You!

Welcome to the Witten Farm Market Bakery, where your favorite treats are freshly baked every day at our year-round Farm Market. Indulge in our mouthwatering selection, from delectable fruit and cream pies to our renowned Grandma Sally pies, all crafted with love and bursting with flavor. Whether you’re in the mood for cookies, brownies, cheesecake, or cinnamon rolls, our array of baked goods will satisfy your cravings and keep you coming back for more. Ready to treat yourself? Visit us today and experience the delightful home-baked goodness that makes us the go-to bakery in town!

Traditional Pies

Bakery Pre-Orders

Our fresh, delicious bakery items are made daily, all year long! With over 5,000 pies flying out of our ovens in just three days for Thanksgiving, it’s clear we’re doing something right. To make sure you don’t miss out on your favorite treats for the holidays, we recommend placing your pre-orders early. For details on pickup, check out our Pre-order Pickup page.

Important Pre Order Information!

Where to Find Us:
Our bakery goodies are available exclusively at our year-round location at 3341 Winchester Pike, Columbus, OH 43232. Drop by to explore our irresistible selection. Find directions on our Locations page.
Pre-Order Anytime:
Place your bakery pre-orders online 24/7 for added convenience! 10% OFF Online Orders!
Order Notice:
We need about 24 hours to prepare your order. When placing your order, simply select your preferred pickup date and time.
Payment:
Pay at the market when you pick up your order.
Pickup Policy:
If you miss your scheduled pickup time, no problem! We’ll hold your order until the end of the day—except for Thanksgiving orders, which must be picked up at your chosen time due to high demand.
Supply Updates:
Occasionally, supply issues may arise beyond our control. If there are any changes to your order, we’ll contact you immediately.
Large Orders:
For pre-orders of 10 or more items, please call ahead at (614) 235-2014 to ensure timely preparation.
Changes or Cancellations:
Need to make a change or cancel your order? Call us at (614) 235-2014.
Order your bakery favorites today and enjoy freshly baked goodness from Witten Farm Market!

Pies

All your favorites baked fresh every day!

2-Crust Pies

Our 2-Crust Pies feature a perfectly golden, flaky top and bottom crust, sealing in the rich, flavorful fillings for a truly irresistible treat.  

(*Seasonal)

Cream Pies

Our rich and velvety cream pies are a customer favorite, each filled with smooth, luscious flavors and topped to perfection.

cream pies

Grandma Sally’s Signature Pies*

Grandma Sally’s Signature Pies are  a one-crust wonders made with the freshest seasonal fruits, offering a timeless taste of Witten Family heritage.

Showcasing our own fruits and berries, made famous by Witten’s Grandma Sally.

(*These pies are only available when fresh, seasonal fruit is in harvest.)

Multiple Pies

My letter to Grandma Sally...

My mother always said we did not come from an artistic family, but I beg to differ.  While we may not be artists in the traditional sense, we all have our own way of adding beauty to the world: for my mother, it is through her quilts, for me it is through my garden and for my Grandma Sally, it was through her pies.  

Everyone in our hometown knows my Grandma Sally was famous for two things:playing cards and baking pies.  If you invited her to an event, you could only hope that she would bring one of those sweet pies filled with the freshest of fruit. Strawberry, peach, blackberry and raspberry were just a few of her favorites.  She would roll out a perfectly flaky crust and carefully pinch the edge around the pan before filling it with whatever fruit was in season. She would meticulously choose the best looking pieces of fruit to sit at the top of her pies and she would arrange them so they made a spectacular display.  When she baked 2-crust pies, she would add her signature flower design to the top crust. Grandma’s pies were beautiful. She worked so hard on her pies, she wanted to make sure that everyone had a chance to try them. At holiday gatherings, you would often find her monitoring the dessert table to make sure none of us took more than one slice.  

I had the opportunity to spend hours in the kitchen with my Grandma Sally over the years, learning how to perfect my pie crusts and make those sweet fruit fillings.  I am now excited to share her recipes with you. I am sure you will enjoy my Grandma Sally’s Signature pies as much as I have over the years.

Julie Witten

 

Cookies

Indulge in our decadent cookies, ranging from colossal gourmet treats to unique daily specialties, ensuring there’s something for every sweet tooth.

Gourmet Cookies
As. Big. As. Your. Face.

Specialty Cookies
Unique flavors that vary daily.

Variety Cookies
All the classics…you’ll need more than one.

No-Bake Cookies
Chewy & Sweet. Need we say more? To Die For!!

variety of cookies
cookies and milk

Fudge

Try it before you buy it.  Ask our team for a sweet sample and decide which flavor is your favorite.

Fudge

Buckeyes and Turtles

Hand-dipped and irresistibly delicious, our Buckeyes and Turtles are the perfect chocolate treats that are sure to satisfy your sweet cravings!

turtles

Brownies

Indulge in our rich and fudgy brownies—available plain, with walnuts or Buckeye -Peanut Butter Icing—and don’t forget to pair them with a glass of Herszler milk; our creamy cheesecakes on a graham cracker crust are simply perfection!

brownies

Cheesecake

Creamy and smooth on a graham cracker crust…it’s the perfect cheesecake.

Velvet Ice Cream

Indulge in our locally made Velvet Ice Cream—a delightful frozen treat that’s sure to bring a smile to every face!  Enjoy in a cone or in a cup with traditional tastes and seasonal flavors.

Breads

Experience the comforting taste of home with our moist and delicious classic breads and sweet biscuits, perfect for summertime favorites like strawberry shortcakes or paired with our local jams and jellies. As the fall and holiday seasons approach, indulge in the warmth of our seasonal treats that evoke cherished memories of family gatherings and festive celebrations!

Bread

Don’t Forget These Other Sweet Treats…

Scroll to Top